Pages

Showing posts with label Ideas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ideas. Show all posts

Wednesday, 11 July 2012

Summary - The Precession of Simulacra (Simulacra and Simulation)


Title of the book: Simulacra and Simulation
Title of the chapter: The Precession of Simulacra
Author: Jean Baudrillard
Publisher:  University of Michigan Press
Date published: April 1985

Theme: Hyperreality
Politics
Simulacra and Simulation
Society

Summary of text:

Jean Baudrillard within the first chapter of his book "Simulacra and Simulation" argues that that boundaries between the real and unreal have be come blurred and have created a new state that he defined as being hyperreal.

He uses an example from a Borges fable where an empire and a map of the empire has the same scale as each other, and as the empire reduces in scale and size so does the map reduced in size and becomes frayed at the edges with the remains being left in the deserts. Baudrillard argues that this is a perfect example of a simulation. However today the representation is no longer that of the map or the mirror and the simulation is no longer the territorial. It is the generation by models of a real without origin or reality: a hyperreal.

He goes on further to argue that the real and unreel or simulation have now lost the difference between one and the other and simulation has become real and the real has become the simulation. As Baudrillard puts it "in fact, it is no longer really the real, because no imaginary envelops it anymore. It is a hyperreal… It is no longer a question of imitation, nor duplication, nor even parody. It is a question of substituting the signs of the real for the real…perfectly descriptive machine that offers all the signs of the real and short- circuits all its vicissitudes." Baudrillard argued that the hyperreal therefore is sheltered from any imaginary and from any distance between the real and the imaginary, the simulation is the generation of differences.

Baudrillard put forth's the debate that dissemination is to pretend not to have what one has when simulation is to feign to have what one doesn't have. However simulation is not pretending. When one thinks of being ill one can simply stay in bed however when one is a simulation of illness they produce themselves the symptoms of the illness. Therefore the simulation transcends the difference between the "true" and "false" the "real" and "imaginary". He also argues at this point the known and understood is lost. For example if someone is a simulation of illness, medicine loses its meaning as it only knows how to treat the real illness instead of the simulated illness.

Baudrillard then argues that when this state is reached a new model is introduced entitled "simulacrum". A simulacrum is not unreal, that is to say it never exchanges from the real but exchanges from itself in an uninterrupted circuit without reference or circumference. Whereas representation attempts to absorb simulation by interpreting it as a false representation, simulation envelops the whole edifice of representation itself as a simulacrum.

He goes on to argue that Disneyland is a perfect model of all the entangled order of simulacra, will all the illusions and phantasms that exist in the theme park. He proposes that Disneyland exists in order to hide that it is the "real" country, all the "real" America that is Disneyland. Disneyland is presented as being imaginary in order to make us believe that it is real, where as all of Los Angeles and the rest of America is no longer real but belong to the hyperreal order and to the order of simulation. The imaginary of Disneyland is neither true nor false, it is a deterrence machine set up in order to rejuvenate the fiction of the real in the opposite camp.

Baudrillard compared the Watergate scandal to that in Disneyland and he said that they are perfect to society in the same way. According to Baudrillard Watergate is not a scandal, because it is what everyone is busy concealing, this dissimulation masking a strengthening of morality, of a moral panic as one approaches the primitive mise-en-scène of capital: its instantaneous cruelty, its incomprehensible ferocity, its fundamental immorality - that is what is scandalous, unacceptable to the system of moral and economic equivalence. Watergate was thus nothing but a lure held out by the system to catch its adversaries - a simulation of scandal for regenerative ends.

Baudrillard goes a step further in his argument to consider people in power whether that be heads of state or politicians. He argues that for a long time now the people in power - no matter which one is nothing but a simulacrum of themselves, and only that gives him the power and the quality to govern. No one would grant the least consent, the least devotion to a real person. It is to his double, he being always already dead, to which allegiance is given.

The Loud family is one of Baudrillard's examples of a simulation. The Loud family in 1971 where exposed to 7 months of uninterrupted shooting, 300 hours of non-stop broadcasting, with out the script or a screenplay. The audience was exposed to the dramas, enjoys and unexpected events - in short a non-stop raw historical document. Baudrillard calls this a "TV vérité" (vérité is a French word which means truth and is used to define a genre in which realism and naturalism is portrayed within TV, film and radio.) He concludes by saying that "you are no longer watching television it is television that is watching you (live). You are the model, you are the majority. Such is the watershed of the hyperreal society in which the real is confused with the model…TV is watching us, TV alienates us, TV manipulates us and TV informs us." At this point is where the simulation begins where the two poles can no longer be maintained between passive and active, real and unreal, to inform and to entertain - is where the lines are blurred between difference - one enters into a simulation.


Key points of the text:


  • It is the generation by models of a real without origin or reality: a hyperreal.
  • Simulation has become real and the real has become the simulation.
  • Dissemination is to pretend not to have what one has when simulation is to feign to have what one doesn't have.
  • A simulacrum is not unreal, that is to say it never exchanges from the real but exchanges from itself in an uninterrupted circuit without reference or circumference.
  • Whereas representation attempts to absorb simulation by interpreting it as a false representation, simulation envelops the whole edifice of representation itself as a simulacrum.
  • Disneyland is a perfect model of a simulacra.
  • Watergate is not a scandal, it was a simulation of scandal for regenerative ends.
  • You are no longer watching television it is television that is watching you (live). You are the model, you are the majority. Such is the watershed of the hyperreal society in which the real is confused with the model…TV is watching us, TV alienates us, TV manipulates us and TV informs us.

Key Quote 2-3:
"To dissimulate is to pretend not to have what one has. To simulate is to feign to have what one doesn't have."

"A hyperreal henceforth sheltered from the imaginary, and from any distinctin between the real and the imaginary, leaving room only for the orbital recurrence of models and for the simulated generation of differences."

"Whereas representation attempts to absorb simulation by interpreting it as a false representation, simulation envelops the whole edifice of representation itself as a simulacrum."

My Response:

Baudrillard's theory, is an intriguing and thought-provoking one that has inspired many other theorists and critics who have developed and based there work around he is philosophy. It is also a key theory within post-modernism however throughout the opening chapter of his book he doesn't provide any evidence for his assumptions and judgement and states his ideas as just been factual truth. He does propose his ideas on to reality in the form of Disneyland, Watergate and the Loud family and suggests that these are examples of his theory that he still doesn't give primary or secondary references throughout his chapter. Which leads me to question whether or not he's theory is just that a combination of ideas or if it does have any practical sense with in the world itself.

I think this is a good starting point for further investigation into Baudrillard's theory. And I would like to do more research into the idea of hyperreality with the use of both simulacra and simulation, refocus may be on Facebook in social Internet but also investigating further into the television programme with a Loud family. I also have decided to read other chapters of Baudrillard book to gain more and understanding and receive any other ideas are applicable.

Friday, 6 July 2012

Reconsidered question


After beginning to read articles, that develop my knowledge and understanding about my question and act as a bases to start my report, I have decided that my question; "To what extent is the world we live in a reflection of the world depicted by Orwell in his novel Nineteen Eighty-Four?" is too broad for investigation and I need to refine my question so I have a direct focus on a niche area.

After a discussion with my tutor about my concerns, we where able, together, to reconsidered my area for investigation and rewrote the question to reflect this change but also to create a clear focus. My final question that I will be investigating into is: "To what extent are we living in a state of ‘hyperreality’, reflective of the totalitarian state depicted in George Orwell’s ‘1984’."

I feel that this revised question is more appropriate than my previous question as it is tailored to my interests of  George Orwell’s "1984" but also creates a niche area of focus and introduces me to a new term and area to investigate with the addition of "hyperreality". From here I now need to continue reading articles that have a direct focus on my new question and also start to consider my method for primary research.

Monday, 5 March 2012

Newspeak


My notes on the Wikipedia article "Newspeak"

- Deliberately impoverished language promoted by the state.
- A greatly reduced and simplified vocabulary and grammar. 
- This suits the totalitarian regime of the Party.
- To make any alternative thinking "thoughtcrime", or "crime think".
- Impossible by removing any words or possible constructs which describe the ideas of freedom, rebellion.
- Citing examples of dying metaphors, pretentious diction or rhetoric, and meaningless words.

To remove synonyms and antonyms

- Remove all shades of meaning from language, leaving simple dichotomies.
- Which reinforce the total dominance of the State.
- Words served as both nouns and verbs.
- A staccato rhythm of short syllables.
- Words with negative meanings were removed as redundant.
- Comparative and superlative meanings were also simplified.
- Adjectives were formed by adding the suffix "-ful".
- An obedient word with which everyone answered affirmatively to what was asked of them.
- All definitions and words that can be used to argue against Big Brother would be eradicated from the language.
- Newspeak on Esperanto.

To control thought

- Chaucer, Shakespeare, Milton, Byron—they'll exist only in Newspeak versions, not merely changed into something different, but actually contradictory of what they used to be.
- There will be no thought, as we understand it now.
- Generically, Newspeak has come to mean any attempt to restrict disapproved language by agovernment or other powerful entity.

Vocabulary

- "A" group: simple concepts entirely made up words 
- "B" group: convey more complicated ideas political implications "goodthink" roughly means "orthodoxy". 
- "C" group: technical vocabulary. Party does not want its people to be intelligent in multiple fields.

This article has helped me to understand and define Newspeak in a clear and understandable way, giving me better knowledge of Orwell's message and purpose of the novel. I would like to further investigate Esperanto, as from what the article has told me Esperanto is the real world equivalent of Newspeak.


Friday, 2 March 2012

Articles and Notes for Further Reading



From last week to this week I have finished reading the Wikipedia and have also finished reading the London Riot articles by Daivd Buckingham. The Wikipedia articles have reenforced my understand of "Doublethink" and "Newspeak". However the London Riot has introduced me to a new way of looking at the media and how thay constructed information to persuade society. Mr Michie and I have had another discussion on what I have just read and how some on that will help me to understand to ideas for my essay.

For next week I need to write my notes up for each article and say how my thoughts have changed from reading the article and if there is any further articles to read based on the article. I also need to find three new articles that have something to do with Nineteen Eighty-Four or the media today. My starting place for this would be Baudrillard and 9/11, from the discussion with Mr Michie who directed me into the area.

During next week's meeting I will present my findings and notes from all the articles and discuss how they have effected my understanding and direction of investigation. We will also sit down and consider what I need to do next to progress my project and broaden my understanding.

Friday, 24 February 2012

Key areas of Identification for Further Investigation



To progress from two weeks ago, I have finished reading the novel and also have written up my initial findings and response to Nineteen Eighty-Four. As well as considering areas of interest for further investigation. (See Below) Mr Michie has checked over this and has also sent it out to other people who he knows might have some other elements or ideas for me to consider.

In our meeting this week me and Mr Michie have discuss George Orwell's theories on society and how they are ill-conceived. As his argument is not based on reality as people can not practice doublethink in the way he is arguing. Citizens are not passive to government or media influence, in fact they are active, they will "rise up" against the state.  An example of this is the uprising in egypt against the government, where as in Orwell's novel this is ignored to focus of the idea of control. 

We also identify the areas that I will focus my essay on and also carry out further investigation as well. These areas are:

- Doublethink
- "War in Peace"
- Alliances

For next week I am to read two wikipedia articles one about "Doublethink" and the other about "Newspeak". I am also going to read an article that is about the London Riot by David Buckingham and how the media constructed the publics opinion. This will help me to start to understand different ideas and other arguments for my essay. I can begin to use these as evidence either for or against the argument that world we live in if a reflection of the world depicted by Orwell. I also need to find the defintion of the word "Hyperreality", which will help me to investigate postmodernism.

During next weeks meeting I am to discuss my findings as from the wikipedia articles and how thay has help me to better understand some of the ideas the George Orwell presents in Nineteen Eighty-Four.

Friday, 17 February 2012

Exploring the Text

Exploring the thematic aspects and wider implications of the text and my own response to the way the story is concluded.

George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four poses many questions about society, government, ideologies; and the implications of a totalitarian state. Some of these question are answered within the book, however, others remain questionable. I consider the book to be one of the most important and illuminating novels of the 20th century, with Orwell changing the status quo. The novel challenges the themes of control, with the use of the "Telescreen", "Hate Week", "Big Brother", "New Speak"; and cults and societies such as "Youth League", "The Spies", "Junior Anit-Sex League", but more significantly the "Brotherhood". This  is an underground societies, which is created and falsified by "The Party" (the totalitarian government within 1984) to capture, interrogate and torture the so called members of the society. The implications are felt throughout the book, as the main character Winston Smith sees through the parties mantra to the lies that he is creating on behalf of the party and decides to rebel against them. This is unacceptable and the party has to quash the rebellious attitude by the means of torture and the rehabilitation. This is done in a four step process, the admission by Winston that he is insane, then the psychological manipulation or re-education to the parties way of thinking or ideology and then to "Room 101" for the destruction of all other love apart from the love of Big Brother and finally, death.

The theme of falsification of information and manipulation of people is another important aspect of 1984. The falsification of information is important not just because Winston Smith works in the department where the falsification takes place, but also because the past is changed to reflect the present and the future of "The Party". This is to the extent that even one of the party’s mantras is "Who controls the past, controls the future: who controls the present controls the past." The practice of this can be seen in chapter 17, "If, for example, Eurasia or Eastasia is the enemy today, then that country must always have been the enemy. And if the facts say otherwise then the facts must be altered. Thus history is continuously rewritten. This day-to-day falsification of the past, carried out by the Ministry of Truth." This falsification of every day information has wider implications on the novel, as this contributes to the manipulation of the people. As the history of the country and the people is ever changing, there is no way to prove that the party has ever been wrong, therefore, that people have to take whatever the party said as truth and forget whatever they remember. The changing of information and forgetting the old is reinforced by the manipulation of the citizens of Oceania (the third state that the world is divided into) by the use of "Doublethink" and "Thoughtcrime". Thoughtcrime is simply any thought that is not in accordance with the principles of Ingsoc. (Ingsco is English Socialism.) The party believes that every crime starts with a thought therefore, if they control thought they control crime, hence thoughtcrime. However, what makes this possible to change the information at will, without the citizens being consciously aware that information was being changed, was the practice of every citizens undertaking doublethink. This is having a simultaneous belief in two contradictory ideas. Orwell describes it through Winston’s voice as "…to forget whatever it was necessary to forget, then to draw it back into memory again at the moment when it was needed, and then promptly to forget it again: and above all, to apply the same process to the process itself. That was the ultimate subtlety: consciously to induce unconsciousness, and then, once again, to become unconscious of the act of hypnosis you had just performed. Even to understand the word 'doublethink' involved the use of doublethink." The implications of this on the whole novel are that no one can truly understand or know anything at all, as any information has been falsified but then the citizens are manipulated into forgetting the falsification and forgetting the manipulation. This leaves the whole of society uneasy and unsure of what they know and what they don't know.

Both of these ideas and themes are brought together at the end of the novel to present a new theme of betrayal. "Under the spreading chestnut tree, I sold you and you sold me." The last line of this, implying that no matter how hard or what promises a person makes, in some way everyone is betraying someone else. The way in which the novel is concluded is without doubt, symbolic of the fight, struggle and then the over riding power and control that the party has in it citizens. As the novel starts with Winston not knowing or understanding his place in society, then finding Julia and deciding to rebel against the party and finally finding his place in society by being tortured and then rehabilitated to love Big Brother resulting in his death. The ending and conclusion of the novel leaves me considering the implications of a totalitarian state, that want to control every movement and thought of it's citizens and whether we are at a moment in time where we could go either one way or the other. However, I think that George Orwell is proposing that it does not matter what we do now, as we are and have always been heading towards that state of life, with such devices that can trace, watch and know who, when, where, why, how and what you are doing of every minute of every day.

Ideas and concepts for further investigation:

- Orwell's inspiration
- Technology
- Language
- Control (in both mind and actions)
- "WAR IS PEACE, FREEDOM IS SLAVERY, IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH"
- NewSpeak, Doublethink, Thoughtcrime
- Government
- English Socialism
- Society
- Fear mongering
- "The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism" (Emmanuel Goldstein "The Book")
- Proletariat
- "Written by a committee"

Wednesday, 8 February 2012

Meeting to discuss "Proposal Form"


To progress from last week to this week I have, completed the "Verification of topic and Title" in all aspects. I have sat down with Mr Michie to talk about what I want to do for the project and if there needs to be any changes. We have also drilled my question down, from being very broad to now being a niche, special area of investigation; "To what extent is the world we live in a reflection of the world depicted by Orwell in his novel Nineteen Eighty-Four?"  

Next week is half term, during this I should have completed read the novel and start to consider different aspects, that can compare to the world that we live in. After finishing reading the novel I am to write an  exploratory blog post sharing my initial reactions to Orwell’s ideas. I should consider both the thematic aspects of the text and their wider implications, as well as my own response to the way the story is concluded. I feel that to proceed with this I need to identify specific ideas and concepts from within the text for further investigation.

After I have completed my reading and have written up my findings, me and Mr Michie will meet again to discuss my response to the novel, will narrow down the areas that I have identify for further investigation and finally start on secondary research. For this research I will be reading articles that analyse different events in the media and how they have been represented. Also, researching into the background ideas of Nineteen Eighty-Four, such as "Doublethink" and "NewSpeak".